Product Manager or Political Manager?
Thriving in the Messy Middle of Influence and Politics
Welcome to No BS Product Management, your weekly guide to mastering the product management journey—from breaking into the role to crushing it as an APM.
Each week, I share no-nonsense advice, practical tips, and real-world strategies to help you handle tricky scenarios, impress your stakeholders, and level up your PM game.
If you’re ready to stop guessing and start thriving in the world of product management, hit that subscribe button now! 🚀
Let’s rip off the Band-Aid right away: politics isn’t just a side effect of product management—it’s woven into the very fabric of the role. You can hate it. You can try to ignore it. But if you want to survive and thrive, you’ll need to embrace it.
I know this isn’t what you signed up for. You wanted to solve user problems, launch cool products, and be the hero who makes everything better. And you can still be that. But here’s the twist: product management is as much about managing people, egos, and priorities as it is about managing roadmaps. The sooner you accept this reality, the easier it becomes.
It’s not about “playing politics” in the shady, manipulative sense. It’s about understanding dynamics, building relationships, and influencing outcomes in a world where decisions aren’t always logical. And yes, it can be exhausting. But trust me, it’s part of the job—just like writing specs or running stand-ups.
The Unspoken Truth About Influence
Let’s talk about influence, the supposed crown jewel of a PM’s skill set. It’s a romantic idea, isn’t it? That you’ll walk into a meeting, present a perfectly crafted argument, and everyone will nod along in agreement because you’re that convincing.
The reality? Influence is messier than that. It’s about aligning people who often have conflicting priorities. And sometimes, your well-researched ideas will hit a brick wall because of decisions made far above your pay grade.
I remember one of my early projects where I poured my heart into building a roadmap. It was based on meticulous user research, competitive analysis, and every data point I could gather. I was sure it was bulletproof. But then leadership decided to pivot. It was like a slap in the face. I felt sidelined, almost betrayed.
What I didn’t realize back then was this: their decision wasn’t a rejection of my work. It was a reflection of broader strategic priorities I had no idea about. My mistake wasn’t in creating the roadmap—it was in failing to align my efforts with the bigger picture.
When Things Get Personal
And then there’s the dreaded blame game. Deadlines slip, priorities change, and fingers inevitably start pointing. Even when you’ve done everything right, you might find yourself in the crosshairs.
I’ve been there. The first time it happened to me, I was pissed. How could I be blamed for delays caused by unforeseen dependencies? But reacting emotionally only made things worse. Over time, I learned to lean into transparency.
Instead of getting defensive, I started laying out the facts calmly. I’d share what went wrong, why it happened, and what we were doing to course-correct to the management chain. Most of the time, that was enough to diffuse the situation. And if it wasn’t? I reminded myself to trust the process. Good managers will see through the noise.
A Lesson in Humility
One of my biggest political blunders came when I was building a 0-to-1 product in an industry I was completely new to. My first release saw moderate success—enough to build on incrementally. But I was eager to make a big splash, so I pushed for a bold pivot.
It was risky, and I didn’t have unanimous support. Still, I forged ahead, convinced that I knew best. The product didn’t crash and burn, but it didn’t take off either. Worse, I’d alienated key stakeholders in the process. The environment became so hostile that I eventually had to leave.
Looking back, I realize the pivot wasn’t the real issue. The problem was how I handled it. If I’d taken the time to collaborate, incorporate feedback, and bring people along for the ride, things might have turned out differently. Relationships are as important as results, if not more so.
So, What’s the Fix?
1. Build Relationships Before You Need Them
Why this matters: Trust and rapport are the currency of influence. When stakeholders trust you, they’re more likely to support your ideas—even in challenging situations.
How to do it:
Don’t wait for a crisis to start conversations. Set up regular coffee chats or informal syncs with key stakeholders to understand their priorities and concerns.
Make an effort to celebrate wins together, whether it’s completing a milestone or addressing a tricky problem.
Treat your stakeholders as partners, not obstacles.
Pro tip: Always ask, “How can I help the team succeed?” Showing interest in shared goals strengthens your relationship.
2. Understand the Bigger Picture
Why this matters: Sometimes, your ideas clash with leadership decisions because they align with a vision you’re not fully aware of. Aligning your efforts with the organization’s strategy will make your work more impactful.
How to do it:
Invest time in learning the company’s mission, long-term goals, and leadership priorities.
Connect your product decisions to strategic outcomes. Frame your recommendations in terms of ROI, customer value, or alignment with leadership’s objectives.
When possible, shadow senior leaders in key discussions to grasp their perspectives.
Pro tip: If you’re unsure about leadership’s priorities, don’t hesitate to ask your manager or trusted peers for guidance.
3. Communicate Transparently and Regularly
Why this matters: Lack of communication leads to misalignment, assumptions, and conflicts. Being proactive with updates can help you steer the narrative.
How to do it:
Share status updates frequently through structured reports, dashboards, or short syncs.
Highlight risks and blockers early, along with your plan to address them. This builds confidence in your problem-solving ability.
Use storytelling to make dry updates engaging—talk about customer impact, progress against goals, or team wins.
Pro tip: In tough situations, focus on what’s next. Acknowledge what went wrong, but quickly pivot to solutions.
4. Pick Your Battles with Care
Why this matters: Not every conflict is worth escalating. Learning to prioritize where to push back and where to compromise is crucial for maintaining relationships.
How to do it:
When faced with opposition, ask yourself: “Does this directly impact the product’s success or my team’s ability to deliver?”
For low-stakes issues, compromise where possible. Save your energy for high-impact decisions.
When you do push back, back your position with data and frame it in terms of shared success.
Pro tip: Sometimes, winning people over is as simple as framing your disagreement as a collaborative discussion: “How can we make this work together?”
5. Foster a Collaborative Culture
Why this matters: When people feel heard and valued, they’re more likely to align with your vision. Collaboration isn’t just good for morale—it’s good for outcomes.
How to do it:
Facilitate workshops or brainstorming sessions where stakeholders can share input.
Actively listen and integrate their feedback into the product where it makes sense.
Show people how their contributions have shaped decisions.
Pro tip: Create a shared “north star” for your team and stakeholders—something everyone can rally around, like a key user outcome or a bold product vision.
6. Be Patient, but Stay Persistent
Why this matters: Navigating office politics isn’t a sprint—it’s a marathon. Relationships, trust, and influence take time to build.
How to do it:
Take a long-term view. If a decision doesn’t go your way today, use the experience to better understand the dynamics for next time.
Keep showing up with consistent effort and a positive attitude, even in challenging situations.
Reflect on political setbacks as learning opportunities—ask yourself what you could have done differently and apply those lessons.
Pro tip: Remember, you’re playing the long game. Building a strong reputation as a fair, reliable PM will pay off in ways you can’t predict.
7. Use Data as a Neutral Ally
Why this matters: In political situations, emotions and opinions can cloud judgment. Data provides an impartial lens to refocus the conversation.
How to do it:
Always have key metrics ready to back your arguments—whether it’s user research, customer feedback, or performance analytics.
Use visualizations like charts or dashboards to simplify complex points.
Avoid weaponizing data to “win” arguments. Instead, position it as a way to guide collaborative decisions.
Pro tip: When there’s a lack of clarity, propose small experiments to gather new data. It’s harder to argue against actionable insights.
8. Be Human
Why this matters: At its core, politics is about people. Showing vulnerability, empathy, and authenticity goes a long way in building goodwill.
How to do it:
Admit when you don’t have all the answers—it’s okay to say, “I need time to think this through.”
Show appreciation for others’ efforts, even if you don’t agree with their views.
Share personal anecdotes or challenges to foster connection.
Pro tip: A little humor can diffuse tense situations. Use it sparingly but effectively to lighten the mood.
The Silver Lining
Here’s the thing about politics: once you learn to navigate it, it can actually become a strength. It teaches you empathy, sharpens your communication skills, and makes you a better collaborator.
And when you see it as part of the job—not an annoying side quest—it stops feeling so overwhelming. It’s not easy, but it’s worth it.
So the next time you’re caught in the middle of office politics, remember: this is just as much a part of product management as building roadmaps or launching features. Embrace it, learn from it, and let it make you stronger.
Because at the end of the day, being a great PM isn’t just about managing products. It’s about managing people, too.
If you think the article helped you, Please subscribe and help my voice reach other PMs.